Tuesday, July 31, 2007

Do American Doctors Make Too Much Money?

Many approaches have been advanced to lower the American health costs. These include,

•Introducing a single payer system.

•Forcing cuts in prescription drug prices

•Eliminating insurance company profits

Now American liberals, academicians, think-tank leaders, and reformers have added a new twists: Reduce American physicians incomes by not paying so much for procedures and by placing doctors on salaries.
Here are a few critics’ comments, as quoted in a July 29 Sunday NYT piece (Alex Berenson, “Sending Back the Doctor’s Bill”).

•Dana Goldman, director of health economics, RAND Corporation, on diabetes care, “The doctor is paid to check his feet, they’re paid to check his eyes, they’re not paid to make sure he goes out and exercises, and really, that may be the most important thing. The whole health system is set up to pay for services that are rendered when the patient, and society is interested in health.”

•Peter Bach , M.D., pulmonary specialist at Sloan Kettering and former senior adviser to Medicare and Medicaid, “The problem is the way they are paid. They have to do stuff. They have to do procedures.”

•Stephen Zuckerman, MD, health economist at the Urban Institute, “There’s not a lot of utilization review or prior authorization. If you’re doing the work, you can expect to get paid.”

•Alan Gerber, MD, director of the Center for Health Policy at Stanford University, “The United States should move toward paying doctors fixed salaries, plus bonuses based on the health of patients they care for.”

In other words, if we could only place doctors on salaries, stop giving them incentives to do procedures, encourage them to provide preventive counseling, and reward them with bonuses for good outcomes, we could “significantly” reduce health costs.

Well, maybe. So far , P4P (pay-for-performance) with small bonuses for meeting quality indicators hasn’t consistently produced good outcomes or lowered costs, paying doctors bonuses in the United Kingdom for meeting quality indicators has cost more than projected and has driven the National Health Service more deeply into debt, and the American people don’t seem to mind American doctors being well paid, on average $200, 000 to $300, 000 a year, with about $150,000 for primary care doctors, and as much as an average of $400,000 for some specialists. According to a 2004 survey by the British government, European doctors in 2002 averaged $60,000 to $120,000.

How do academic and think tank critics, generally far removed from the clinical frontlines, know what’s a fair income for American doctors? They seldom provide details or a thoughtful analysis based on life in America. Do they factor in the cost of living and housing is much greater in the U.S, the relentless 3% annual rise in practice expenses sending, the 5-6% annual rise in college tuitions now running abut $30,000 a year, the average debt of doctors entering practice, now in the neighborhood of $150,000. Besides, American doctors’ malpractice rates dwarf those of their European counterparts?

And what about the American culture? Do they know that American patients “expect” to have something concrete done and quickly when they visit a doctor, as small as writing a prescription or as big as having a CT scan or MRI for their bad back or arthritic hip or knee? Are they cognizant most of those participating the American capitalistic society, outside of major corporations, which employ only about 10% of Americans, function on a fee-for-service basis without intervening third parties..

Lastly, is the critics’ assertion realistic that U.S. doctors’ incomes are a “significant factor” in why American health costs surpass those of Europeans by about 50% .

Let’s take some rough numbers. Health costs are now $2.2 trillion in the U.S. About $500 billion of that $2.2 trillion is represented by physician incomes. Now let’s say Medicare goes ahead with its 2008 plan to cut doctors’ incomes by 10%, and health plans follow in lockstep as they have done in the past.. That would cut $50 billion from the $2.2 trillion, a 2.3% reduction of the total the U.S. spends on health care, a large amount but probably not significant in reducing the health care gap in national health spending.

Medicare lowering of doctors’ incomes has consequences. AMA surveys indicate as many as 30% of physicians say will no longer accept Medicare patients if the 10% cut goes through, and if Congress follows through with a 40% reduction over the next five years, the number approaches 50%, and Medicare recipients will have to scramble to find care. Projected lower incomes would likely persuade talented college graduates to enter fields other than medicine and worsen the doctor shortage, estimated to be 50,000 by 2010 and $200,000 by 2020. Why would any bright young person spend 11 to 15 years preparing for a profession in which systematic fee reductions are guaranteed ?

7 comments:

ObGynThoughts said...

I let Germany and came to the US because physicians earn more. I disliked the "employee approach" that many physicians have in Germany. Well, why should I kill myself working, they don't pay me that much anyway...
If you want independent people to become employees and then pay them less, that is your choice. But DO NOT EXPECT that they are going to go the extra mile for you. Hey, they'll just shrug and sign you out to the next shift...Now imagine that when being in intensive care, imagine that when someone operates on you..
And the next step is always: more control, more surveillance, more forms to fill
People, that just does not work. It is the same in medicine as it is in every other field: you get what you pay for. In medicine people are just spoiled, usually they get more than they pay for and they logical thought is that they want even more...

ken2012 said...

The arresting and acutely feminine Chanel Watch from the Damiani cast pays admiration to the aboriginal years of the 20th century, aswell accepted as the “age of beauty”. This era was characterized by the admiration of the new generation’s assembly to accurate themselves and to adore activity to its fullest.

Anonymous said...

Take attention when treating the Impetigo so as urine and detergent and Ne'er take up anyone else's for any ground.
In some extreme cases impetigo can trail to austere complications such as quick piss and scoop antiseptic.


Visit my page - impetigo emedicine
my web site :: bacterial infection on skin pictures

Anonymous said...

[url=http://sacsonline4u.webnode.fr]sac longchamp solde[/url] 锘縩s depuis des d茅cennies.Avec beaucoup de styles et de finitions au choix, votre produit sera 茅blouir en couleur de haute qualit茅.D'une part, les deux sont faits d'un tissu r茅sistant qui vous tient po Cela signifie, graisse et la graisse non d茅sir茅e reste cach茅 et aplati si les v锚tements sont assez serr茅s.on dont l'envie vous sac pliable longchamps en prend.l sac lomgchamp pour ce No.Il sont juste plusieurs choses qui pourraient 锚tre faites avec l'argent 脿 l'heure actuelle en dehors de le porter pour compl茅ter la tenue et donnant un total de d茅clarations de mode de nouveaux qui refl猫te l'originalit茅 du caract猫re unique d'une personne.Si vous aimez la musique et que vous voulez 茅couter la fa.Les gens ne sacs lonchamps vous. [url=http://lvhandbagstore.blinkweb.com]lvhandbagstore.blinkweb.com[/url]

[url=http://sneakersshop.blinkweb.com]isabel marant[/url] 锘縡or a women-specific golf bag follow this guide to choosing the right one for you
[url=http://onlinesneakers.webnode.fr]isabel marant sneakers[/url]This catalog is often beyond the normal girl's price range.They are common throughout the west and are often worn for business.Whether they are strapless or not, isabel marant top they are alluring while still leaving much to the imagination.That additionally includes the actual high-tech producing o.
[url=http://sacssolde.webnode.fr]longchamp sac[/url] 锘縯 doit demander sp茅cialiste de v锚tements pour hommes pour l'aider 脿 d茅cider sur le meilleur style pour sa silhouette.Que vous portez des lunettes de mode, lunettes de cr茅ateur, lunettes de vue, lunettes sans ordonnance, lunettes de sport, lunettes de sport ou d'actualisation des lunettes il ya une paire de maroquinerie longchamp lunettes et verres de lunettes en fonction de vos besoins.), Vous ne devriez pas perdre votre c.Voici quelques conseils pour obtenir une offre sp茅ciale sur votre pull en cachemire, des chaussettes, et plus encore.Quoi qu'il en soit vous enfiler, robes de soir茅e strictement porte monnaie longchamp formels ou semi tenue de f锚te d茅contract茅e, votre robe doit avoir 1 facteur de fa.Pas tout le longchamp.fr monde de la mod茅lisation de la.
[url=http://lvhandbagstore.blinkweb.com]lvhandbagstore.blinkweb.com[/url]


[url=http://buxtalk.com/index.php?action=profile;u=20907]sacsonline4u.webnode.fr/Hy4[/url]
[url=http://forums.blind-mind.com/index.php?PHPSESSID=c257bb02514a47ea9d49dbccf0e6fbb6&action=profile;u=17969]sacssolde.webnode.fr/Ai4[/url]
[url=http://www.jtv.cc/forum/member.php?17712-Gisyinava]sacssolde.webnode.fr/Ss4[/url]

Anonymous said...

It is Miuccia [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]шуба [/url] and Patrizio Bertelli who find the secret of Prada and invent the very first black nylon Prada handbag on the globe which opens the successful and beneficial entrance of world famous handbag brand. Prada Handbags is known for its luxurious. Each woman wants a Prada handbag which signifies the fashion and the way of life. Prada store sells cheap Prada, including Prada purses and Prada handbags. [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]шуба [/url] is a better way for you to pick a bag of high quality and greatest designed. With the expansion of Prada, increasingly more [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]шубы из китая [/url] are established. Getting Prada handbags and Prada wallets in [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]шубы от производителя [/url] can help you save a large number of time and cash. [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]Шубы оптом [/url] is yet another good choice for you. [url=http://www.furworld.ru/ ]шубы от производителя [/url] will never disappoint you.

Anonymous said...

It is not my first time to pay a visit this website, i am visiting this site dailly and get nice information from here all
the time.

My website; Kris Letang Authentic Jersey

Anonymous said...

This information is priceless. Where can I find out more?


Also visit my web-site :: http://slc-wireless.com/