Tuesday, May 24, 2016


Not Good, Accentuate the Negative, Eliminate the Positive
Maybe I’ve been watching too much TV, scanning the Internet too obsessively, and reading too many newspapers, but I have the impression the public and our presidential candidates are stressing the negative at the expense of the positive, and the past instead of the future. 
As one sage observed,   pessimists see the whole, optimists the donut.   It’s the old glass half-empty, glass half-full story.    I see the situation through the eyes of Pogo pungently noted, “We have met the enemy, and he is us.”   America is at war with itself, and with bureaucracies or at the TSA, the VA, the ACA, and at the capitol of the USA.
Consider health care.  If you view our system through technological lenses, we have the world’s most advanced health system, with excellent results among those receiving joint replacements, receiving stents for clogged arteries, and waiting for specialty care.   
Sure, we have our problems -   high costs, unaffordable deductibles,  9% of our populace still uninsured , a growing shortage of primary care physicians, and an access mess as more physician s no longer accept Medicare, Medicaid, and subsidized ObamaCare patients because of low fees and  interventional hassles.     
But we have well-trained and well-intended physicians,    widely dispersed life-saving and life-style enhancing technologies, excellent medical researchers, and, not to be discounted, the most productive economy on the planet.
And as a nation with a creed of freedom, choice, and opportunities, we still have positive choices.   
We can either accept the notion, advanced by Hillary Clinton, that the status quo with a few fixes will make things OK.  
We can believe Bernie Sanders’ free lunch theory, that there’s always somebody rich out there who will pay the freight.  
We can take Donald Trump at his word that he can make America great again if we only negotiate better deals with other nations, blow-up the D.C.  establishment, and blow ISIS to hell.
I believe once we rid ourselves of bureaucratic and political deadwood,   return to our traditions of individual choice and freedom,   rid ourselves of extreme ideologies,   free ourselves of mandates, respect our physicians, and swing back to the center, we will right the nation’s ship.

Monday, May 23, 2016


Federal Judge Rules ObamaCare Subsidies Illegally Funded
May Day!  May Day!
On May 12 U.S. Dictrict Court Judge Rosemary Collyer ruled that the Obama administration implemented health exchange subsidies illegally.  
The subsidies would funnel $130 billion to insurers over the next decade.  Only Congress, said the judge,  has the power to appropriate funds.  The House of Representative launched the suit maintained  the subsidies violated the legislative’s branch’s power of the purse.
The decision does not necessarily spell the end  of ObamaCare subsidies, of ObamaCare itself.  The program won’t shut down immediately until the government’s appeal works its way through the system. The administration argues the ruling was due to an “inartful  drafting” of the law.  Similar arguments have been made in two previous  Supreme Court decisions which upheld the constitutionality of the law.   Still,  according to the Wall Street Journal, “there’s a plausible case to be made that the law is a patchwork legislative mess that doesn’t hold together  without a willingness to engage in illegal and unconstitutional implementation.”

Sunday, May 22, 2016


Limits of Societal and Health Care Intervention
There is a proper measure of all things, certain limits beyond which and short of which  is not to be found.

Horace (65-8BC), Satires
50% to 70% of all premature deaths could be prevented if only people stopped smoking, ate a proper diet, kept a healthy weight, exercised a half-hour each day, followed doctors’ orders,  took their prescriptions,   stayed away from opioids and other addictive drugs ,  didn’t text while driving,  otherwise behaved themselves,  individually, collectively, and nonviolently,  we would all be better off.  But that is not to be.
Humans Are Humans
But alas, humans are humans.  No tree grows to the sky, very few people live past 100, and government cannot control how people or societies behave.
Limits
There are limits of how much government can do to protect us against ourselves and improve our health.    It can pass ObamaCare with its 400,038 pages of regulations and its $2.5 trillion in costs over the next decade, and it can institute 114 laws with 3410 regulations,  as it has done during Obama’s reign, to protect people against profit-seeking corporations and doctors.
Cost and Hassle Factor for Doctors
To control costs,   it can cut doctors’ pay to below Medicare, which is roughly 80% of private pay.   It can create and add  to the  Hassle Factor for doctors -  defined as any time-consuming  paperwork-ridden maneuver required of physicians to satisfy  3rd party payer s– Medicare, Medicaid, or insurers ,- who provide payment for any treatment, service,  procedure, or drug.
Unfortunately,  The Hassle Factor results in:
1.        Reduced benefits for the patient 

2.       Decreased number of primary care doctors

3.      Erosion of physician-patient relationship 

4.      Higher costs

Higher Taxes
Government can raise taxes, such as these for ObamaCare.
60.1 Billion: Tax on Health Insurers (Takes effect Jan. 2014): Annual tax on  industry imposed relative to health insurance premiums collected that year.  Phases in gradually until 2018.  Fully-imposed on firms with $50 million in profits.
$32 Billion: Excise Tax on Comprehensive Health Insurance Plans (Takes effect Jan. 2018): Starting in 2018, new 40 percent excise tax on “Cadillac” health insurance plans ($10,200 single/$27,500 family). 
$23.6 Billion: “Black liquor” tax hike (Took effect in 2010) This is a tax increase on a type of bio-fuel
$22.2 Billion: Tax on Innovator Drug Companies (Took effect in 2010): $2.3 billion annual tax on the industry imposed relative to share of sales made that year
$20 Billion: Tax on Medical Device Manufacturers (Takes effect Jan. 2013): Medical device manufacturers employ 360,000 people in 6000 plants across the country. This law imposes a new 2.3% excise tax. 
$15.2 Billion: High Medical Bills Tax (Takes effect Jan 1. 2013): Currently, those facing high medical expenses are allowed a deduction for medical expenses to the extent that those expenses exceed 7.5 percent of adjusted gross income (AGI). 
$13.2 Billion: Flexible Spending Account Cap  (Takes effect Jan. 2013): Imposes cap on FSAs of $2500 (now unlimited).  Indexed to inflation after 2013. 
 $5 Billion: Medicine Cabinet Tax (Took effect Jan. 2011): Americans no longer able to use health savings account (HSA), flexible spending account (FSA), or health reimbursement (HRA) pre-tax dollars to purchase non-prescription, over-the-counter medicines (except insulin).
$4.5 Billion: Elimination of tax deduction for employer-provided retirement Rx drug coverage in coordination with Medicare Part D (Takes effect Jan. 2013).
$4.5 Billion: Codification of the “economic substance doctrine” (Took effect in 2010): This provision allows the IRS to disallow completely-legal tax deductions and other legal tax-minimizing plans just because the IRS deems that the action lacks “substance” and is merely intended to reduce taxes owed.
$2.7 Billion: Tax on Indoor Tanning Services (Took effect July 1, 2010): New 10 percent excise tax on Americans using indoor tanning salons.
$1.4 Billion: HSA Withdrawal Tax Hike (Took effect Jan. 2011): Increases additional tax on non-medical early withdrawals from an HSA from 10 to 20 percent, disadvantaging them relative to IRAs and other tax-advantaged accounts, which remain at 10 percent.
$0.6 Billion: $500,000 Annual Executive Compensation Limit for Health Insurance Executives (Takes effect Jan. 2013(,
$0.4 Billion: Blue Cross/Blue Shield Tax Hike (Took effect in 2010): The special tax deduction in current law for Blue Cross/Blue Shield companies would only be allowed if 85 percent or more of premium revenues are spent on clinical services.
More Regulations and Higher Taxes Have Little Effect on Health Status
But more regulations and higher taxes rarely change a nation’s health status or how patients behave.  In 2006,  Satcher and Pamies pointed out  in their book  Multicultural Medicine and Health Differences  that a nation’s health system accounts for only 15% of a nation’s health status, life style makes for 30% and other factors – poverty, inferior education, income differences, and lack of social cohesion make up the other 55%. Therefore, any reform of our system is unlikely to increase the nation’s overall health status.
 In other words, a nation’s culture,   life style habits, and  economic  prosperity  determines its health, not government regulations and taxes.

 

Saturday, May 21, 2016


Telemedicine – Why So Slow to Take Off?
Telemedicine is the use of telecommunication and information technologies to provide clinical health care at a distance. It helps eliminate distance barriers and can improve access to medical services that would often not be consistently available in distant rural communities.
American Telemedicine Association
Twenty years or so ago, my wife and I travelled to China with a Mayo Clinic Group.  While there I met an American business man, who remarked to me. “The next time I hear the word ‘potential’, I’ll kill myself.” He was referring, of course, to the one  billion potential Chinese buyers of American goods.
Members of the American Telemedicine Association, founded in 1993, at the dawn of the Internet and the Information Age, must feel the same.  Telemedicine or medicine at a distance, has been touted for more than 20 years as the Holy Grail for American health consumers, particularly those in rural regions, or those unable to travel to see a doctor. 

Telemedicine transcends place.   You don’t need to be near them  to see doctors.    Your doctor can communicate with by Skype, or some other form of visual or electronic means.
Telemedicine is full of enthusiasts -  and telemedicine-leaning websites, 3000 by some estimates.

Predictions for Telemedicine in 1999, the Dawn of the Information Age
 In 1999, James Dale Davidson, a venture capitalist, and Lord William Rees-Mogg, director of a private bank in London, wrote,
“One day soon, if you have a stomachache, you will be able to consult a digital doctor, an expert system with encyclopedia knowledge of symptoms, maladies, and antidotes.  It will access your medical history in encrypted form: ask whether  you pains happen after eating or before meals.  Whether it is sharp or dull, persistant or episodic.  Whatever questions doctors ask,the digital doctor will ask, It may determine that you drink too much wine, or not enough .  You may be referred to a cyberspecialist. If you need operation , a cybersurgeon in Bermuda, may do an operation long-distance with the aid of specialized equipment tha performs micro-incisions.(The Sovereign Individual; Mastering the Transition to the Information Age, Simon and Schuster).

Telemedicine in 2014
In 2014,  Jeff Boss . a former Navy SEAL, waxed ecstatic  about the potential  of  telemedicine. In an August  22 Forbes article (“The New Face of HealthCare Innovation: 7 Ways Telemedicine  Changes the Healthcare Landscape and for the Better.”), he cited 7 advantages of telemedicine for health consumers and doctors.
1. Stronger relationships. It offers the luxuries of personalization and convenience without exposing yourself or your child to the 15 other sickly patients normally waiting in your doctor’s office.
2. Convenience.  Rather than having to trek into the doctor’s office for a consult, you can now do so from the comfort of your own smartphone for follow up visits, after hours calls, or while traveling. Additionally, parents gain a stronger piece of mind because they can immediately reach their doctor for relatively benign symptoms such as a cough or runny nose.
3. Reduced complexity. Complexity is defined by the speed at which industries change and the interdependence of relationships therein. Telemedicine reduces both.
4. Greater awareness. For physicians, pop-up windows alert the provider of possible medication side effects for greater drug reconciliation.
5. Shared purpose.  It  makes life easier for parents, caregivers and families in an increasingly complex healthcare envirironoment
6. Improved efficiency. Telemedicine eliminates phone consults and the addiction to answering emails.
7. Enhanced flexibility for physician.The changing landscape of healthcare offered through smartphone apps allows doctors to build stronger relationships with their patients rather than be just another MD—critical to the “patient” component of “patient care.”

Little Telemedicine Market Penetration
In spite of the enthusiasm and hoopla over telemedicine’s potential,  telemedicine has not significantly penetrated health care.   In 2013,  only 1% of Medicare’s 55 million beneficiaries  participated in telemedicine visits,  and just  1.3% of  233,000 California Public Employees Retirement System members chose virtual telemedicine visits over traditional office visits.  In a widely touted and well-funded effort by HealthSpot, in collaboration with Rite Aid drugstore, to market telemedicine kiosks ended in bankruptcy in 2016

Why So Slow?
Why has telemedicine been so slow to be adapted by health consumers and physicians?
Here are a few  reasons why.
1)      Physician office visits do not lend themselves to  virtual visits.  It's human nature.   People like to talk to people , not computers, or algorithms posing at people,  or people at a distance.  Telemedicine visits, are, after all, virtual – i.e. not the real thing -  compared to a face-to-face physical encounter with a physician.

2)     Reimbursement for telemedicine varies from state to state,  and has crazy variations and obstacles which are not easy to surmount.

3)     Due to doctor shortages,  most physicians are already too busy with patients to bother with a new form of reimbursement which takes time away from regular patients. 

4)      There is no evidence that virtual visits significantly  improve outcomes or improvements in care.

Thursday, May 19, 2016


Donald Trump,  Bernie Sanders,  Francis  Collins and Causes to Believe In
Quick now!  Put politics and biases aside.
Ask yourself.  What do Donald Trump,  Bernie Sanders, and Francis Collins share in common.
Beliefs
One, they share causes they believe in.
Two, they believe the status quo  is unacceptable.
Indeed, each in their own way vowed to change the status quo because they believe there is a better way.
Donald Trump
Donald Trump believes   making America great and rich again is the answer to our woes.    He believes winning isn’t everything.  It’s the only thing.  He believes he can negotiate any deal to make greatness, wealth, and general prosperity happen again.  He believes  public is fed up with the status quo -  a stagnant economy,  loss of prestige abroad,  and bowing before our enemies –  will never cut it.  He  sincerely believes in himself and  radiates confidence in his beliefs.
Bernie Sanders
Bernie Sanders believes  in a  social revolution  expressing America’s altruism – unselfishness  for others and devotion to the welfare of others.  He believes  that by redistributing wealth,  taxing the rich for their fair share,   providing  Medicare for all,  giving free college tuitions,  rebuilding our infrastructure,  social goodness and equity can be achieved.   He believes the status quo – the income gap between the rich and poor – is evil and can be corrected by a benevolent government.  His passion for his beliefs  is authentic and shines through  in  his personality and his speaking engagements.
Francis Collins
Francis Collins, MD, PhD,  heads up the National Institutes of Health.  He  believes  the status quo, namely  600,000 Americans dying each year of cancer,   1600 people each day,  is intolerable. He believes  a concentrated  effort by scientists can unlock the mysteries  that cause cancer.    He believes winning the war on cancer is doable.  After all,  cancer mortality rates have decreased by 23% over the last 25 years.  Through intensified cancer research,  Collins believes we can defeat cancer in all of its forms by  increasing the  resources devoted to fighting cancer and breaking down silos to unite the cancer-fighting community.How can we do this?  Through focus on cancer vaccines for high risk individuals,  early cancer detection of DNA and RNA byproducts in blood and other fluids,   studying genomic mutations in tumor cells,  by developing tumor-killing immune cells,  screening for the factors that produce pediatric cancers, and  sharing data to handle and analyze genomic and clinical data from patients (Douglas Lowy, MD, and Francis Collins, MD, PhD, “Aiming High – Changing the Trajectory for Cancer, “ New England Journal of Medicine, May 19, 2016).
 Francis and his NIH colleagues “expect these efforts to build a firm foundation for the development of better means of prevention, treatment, and cure of all types of cancer.”
Tyranny of Status Quo
Trump,  Sanders, and Collins do not believe in the tyranny of the status quo, that establishment  pressures to maintain positions of power  to resist change,  are acceptable.   They espouse different means to achieve  their ends,  and all are sincere in their beliefs that their ends justify the means  of improving the lot of humankind.
Hillary Clinton
In  the middle  of the spectrum of change  is Hillary Clinton.  She believes the status quo can be fixed with a tweak here, a tweak there.  She believes caution is the better part of valor, and time will prove that President Obama’s domestic and foreign policies will stand the test of time, and that cautious progressivism  is the best path forward.

Wednesday, May 18, 2016


Notes and Quotes, Number Two
1)      Political Walls

As every political observer knows, there are all sorts of walls -  the Chinese Wall, the Berlin Wall, the Jerusalem Wall.    The latest most controversial walls are Trump’s Mexican Wall and the Benghazi and Rhodes’ Stone Wall.

Moral:  Which brings to mind  these  lines in poet Robert Frost’s poem  Mending Wall, “ Before I built a wall I’d ask to know, What I was walling in or walling out.”

2)     Trending Now Facebook and All The News That’s Fit to Trend
Facebook’s CEO, Mark Zuckerberg, is meeting today with  conservatives to talk about Facebook’s alleged liberal bias in its Trending Now column.    Conservatives say this is important because of Facebook’s huge audience,  estimated at 1.5 billion worldwide, and its reputation as the site where millenials and other Facebook followers get their news.  Facebook insists  its algorithm which produces is politically neutral.
Moral:    Keep in mind behind every algorithm  are human programmers with their own set of biases.
3)     Momentous Momentums
Who is building or losing momentum  after recent political primaries?  The perceptions are:  Hillary Trump is losing momentum,  Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump are gaining  momentum. The question is:  can momentums overcome delegate counts and electoral college votes?  
Moral:   No Mo or Mo Mo, that is the question in today’s Presidential race.
4)     U.S. Uninsured at All Time-Low
According to the Obama administration,
“About 9.1% of people in the U.S., or around 28.6 million, were uninsured in 2015 according to federal statistics released Tuesday. The Obama administration is celebrating the figures—which largely matched an earlier release by the agency for the first half of last year—as proof of the impact of the Affordable Care Act, which overhauled the insurance system, created new subsidies for people to get private coverage and boosted funding for states to expand the Medicaid program that offers near free-care to the lowest-income Americans.” (Wall Street Journal, May 18, 2016)
Moral: Yes, but coverage and access are not the same,  as the NYT pointed out in a 5/17 Sunday piece, “Sorry, We Don’t Take ObamaCare.”
5)    Highmark Sues U.S. over ObamaCare 

Highmark,  a big Pennsylvania, insurer with revenues of $17.5 billion has sued the U.S. government  because it didn’t get $223 million promised in the “risk corroidor” program.  Last year Hallmark lost $58 million, largely on health exchange plans.

Moral:   Risk, but no reward, when the government promises.

6)     Calls for Single-Payer Grow Louder
“In an editorial and proposal published recently in the American Journal of Public Health, 2,231 physicians called for a single-payer national health program to replace the current private insurance model of financing healthcare. 

 While the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act has increased access to healthcare services for millions of people, many physicians still have grave concerns over patients' ability to get the care they need, says Steffie Woolhandler, MD, a co-author of the editorial and proposal.  Woolhandler is a cofounder and board member of Physicians for a National Health Program, a non-profit advocacy group that supports single-payer national insurance.”

The 2231 physicians in Physicians for a National health Program, represent about 2% if all U.S. physicians,  Among other things,  the National Health Program physicians say people will die in the streets without such a program.   The program, of course, is the cornerstone of Bernie Sanders’s “Medicare-for-All” proposal,  projected to cost $15 trillion.  A Gallup poll this week indicates 55% of all Americans now favor a single-payer system,  including  74% of Democrats and 37% of Republicans

Moral:   Single-payer may be the moral thing to do, but it’s going to cost a bundle -$15 trillion which presumably would be piled on top of the current national debt of $19 trillion, expected to grow to $21 trillion by the time Obama leaves office.